Q&A with Dr. Danielle Thomsen, author of "The Money Signal: How Fundraising Matters in American Politics"
In the conversation below, Dr. Danielle Thomsen talks to CAWP senior scholar Dr. Kira Sanbonmatsu about her 2025 book, The Money Signal: How Fundraising Matters in American Politics. The conversation covers the role of early money in U.S. politics, the relationship of self-financing to candidate diversity, the impact of gender on early fundraising, what women candidates need to know, and why women's political giving matters, among other topics. In addition to Thomsen’s book, the scholars explore additional research on gender, race, money, and politics. A complete transcript of the interview appears below.
| Topic | Video Excerpt |
|---|---|
| How Money Matters |
|
| Early Money Matters |
|
| Money Matters throughout the Cycle |
|
| Who Self Funds? |
|
| Advice for Women Candidates |
|
| Party Differences |
|
| Gender and Fundraising Networks |
|
| Women's Giving Matters |
|
Full citation:
Thomsen, Danielle. 2025. The Money Signal: How Fundraising Matters in American Politics. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.
Additional Resources:
Mundy, Ryan, and Danielle M. Thomsen. "Candidate Wealth and Early Money in Congressional Elections." Forthcoming in the American Journal of Political Science.
Plaskon, Savannah, and Danielle M. Thomsen. 2024. "A New Look at Fundraising Hurdles: Race, Gender, and Early Money." Working paper.
Thomsen, Danielle, and Michele L. Swers. 2017. "Which Women Can Run? Gender, Partisanship, and Candidate Donor Networks." Political Research Quarterly 70 (2): 449–63.
For overviews of research on women in U.S. politics, see CAWP's Research Inventory on Gender & Politics, including the overview on Women, Money, and Politics.
Full Transcript
This conversation has been edited for length and clarity.
Friday, Oct 16, 2026
Kira Sanbonmatsu
I'm Kira Sanbonmatsu, senior scholar at the Center for American Women and Politics, and we're here as part of our new program where we are translating research for a broader audience. And I am excited to have with me today the author of the book The Money Signal: How Fundraising Matters in American Politics. I'm very excited to welcome Professor Danielle Thomsen who is associate professor of political science at the University of California, Irvine. Thanks so much for joining us.
Danielle Thomsen
Thank you for having me. It's great to be here.
Kira Sanbonmatsu
I really enjoyed reading your book, and I know our audience is going to be very interested in hearing about it. You recently published The Money Signal: How Fundraising Matters in American Politics. Could you give us the backstory of how you decided to write this book?
Danielle Thomsen
Yes, I started getting interested in this project through my research on dropout candidates. These are individuals who take initial steps to run for office. In particular, they start raising money and file reports with the Federal Election Commission, but ultimately drop out before the primary election, and I found what I thought was a surprising number of individuals who did this, and many of whom directly attributed their decision to drop out to fundraising pressures. And again these were surprising acts because these are among the most strategic candidates who run for office. They do not enter races lightly. They have pre-existing ties and networks, but they decided that staying in the race ultimately wasn't worth it. And I wanted to learn more about why.
In addition, I've been studying congressional elections for over a decade, and I've been struck by how fundraising reaches new highs with almost each election cycle. And I began to think that we were missing something about why fundraising is so important, why fundraising numbers break records each year, and why candidates, in particular, care so much about raising money. So that's what prompted the larger project.
Kira Sanbonmatsu
Those are such important questions, and absolutely, the cost of elections just keep rising. You provide a lot of answers to those important questions in this book. Maybe you could walk us through what you mean by the book's title,The Money Signal. How does the money signal work in congressional elections?
What is “the money signal”?
Danielle Thomsen
The central argument of the book is that money is a widely used signal of viability and strength in contemporary American politics. And money matters because important political actors – I look at candidates, donors, journalists, and party leaders in particular – coordinate around fundraising as a focal point, long before and well after the election. Early money sets the stage and creates expectations about what is likely to come next. There is also really limited information in the pre-primary period, and money is a convenient measure or heuristic for political actors and observers to use.
The bigger point of the book is to shift our attention beyond just the material value of money and highlight its role as a signal that shapes perceptions and behavior in multiple ways across the election cycle. The chapters draw on a lot of data to look at how fundraising works and operates as a signal. The main source I draw on is an original data set of more than 35,000 U.S. House candidates from 1980 to 2022. These data include their pre-election and quarterly FEC reports – anything they filed when they first entered the race to their last report in the race. I also conducted interviews with candidates. I surveyed both candidates and donors. I analyzed newspaper coverage of money, and I looked at committee assignments and legislative success among elected officeholders to illustrate how money serves as a signal and why fundraising is important.
The over-time fundraising data that I mentioned show that the fundraising landscape has really changed dramatically over this four-decade period, with both candidates and officeholders raising more money today and doing so earlier in the election cycle. And early money brings a host of benefits. Top fundraisers are perceived as more formidable and they are less likely to drop out of the race. They fare better in subsequent fundraising. Journalists are more likely to cover their campaigns, and they reap party and policy rewards in office. Those who raise more money are unsurprisingly more likely to win the primary as well. But most of the book focuses on these actors: candidates, donors, journalists, and party leaders, and how they use money as an indicator of strength and support, both very early on in the cycle and even after they win the primary.
Kira Sanbonmatsu
It's a very powerful signal. That's a lot of evidence that you compile over decades to really unpack how that signal plays out. As you know, at CAWP, we've been following women's fundraising and donations in congressional races through our Women, Money, and Politics Watch project, and so based on your book and your related research with Savannah Plaskon and Ryan Mundy, I'm curious if you think the money signal works the same way for women and men candidates. The book provides a lot of evidence about the money signal generally and so I’m wondering about the possible gender breaks.
Danielle Thomsen
The book treats money as an independent variable. So why does money matter in elections for all these different actors and their perceptions and behavior? I think money is valuable across the board for men and women alike. Some of my current work is with terrific UCI graduate students Ryan Mundy and Savannah Plaskon. We are looking at money as a dependent variable and thinking about the factors that shape fundraising and early resources as well. In a paper with Ryan Mundy, we show that wealthy candidates are advantaged in multiple ways in elections, largely through their ability to raise early high-dollar contributions, individual contributions. The most successful non-incumbents, so these are general election winners, received three-fourths of their money in the first 90 days from contributors above $1,000, and almost half from just max-outs alone.
So I think the benefits of raising money accrue to both men and women. But I also think that – as important work by CAWP has also shown – women construct their campaign funds in different ways than men. So in the paper with Savannah Plaskon we find clear differences in early resources by race and gender. We look at early fundraising from 1988 to present across white, Black, Asian, and Latino candidates, and we find that white and Asian men raise between 1.5 to three times as much from donors as Black men, Black women, and Latinas. In addition, white women are among the highest early fundraisers. But they also raise a larger number of contributions, so they likely have to invest more effort to arrive at the same total as their male counterparts – which, as you know, often comes up in conversations with candidates themselves.
Kira Sanbonmatsu
Absolutely. Thanks for sharing that additional work. And it's great to know what's behind-the-scenes of that fundraising – not just what the totals look like, but what goes into it. And that definitely supports some of the work that we've been doing at CAWP. And I wanted to follow up on what you've been arguing about early money. For our audience, early money reminds me of why the women's political action committee EMILY's List was founded. EMILY's List stands for “Early Money is Like Yeast: it makes the dough rise.” And they recognized that early fundraising was missing for women back in the 1980s when they got started. So I'm wondering about the over-time perspective and whether early money has become even more important since then.
Why is early money more important today?
Danielle Thomsen
Yes, EMILY's list was definitely on to something a long time ago. I think early money has become increasingly salient in American politics due to a variety of changes in the political, the electoral, and the technological context. The first, the timeline of congressional elections has moved up due to the decline in competitive districts and the heightened role of primaries. So in many Congresses today, more than 80%, 85% of lawmakers are elected from safe districts where their party has at least a 10-point advantage in the general election. So much of the action, as a result, now happens long before November.
Another change is that even though fundraising data have been publicly available for decades, the rise of the internet and the immediate accessibility of campaign finance reports means that anyone and everyone can access these data more easily than ever. It used to be the case that journalists had to go into the FEC public records office to get actual reports, or they had to call and request to get reports mailed or faxed to them. But today these data are online immediately and very easy for everyone to access and use.
Finally, I think receipts are additionally appealing because of the objectivity of fundraising in our current big data era. Money is measurable. It's comparable across candidates. Candidates either have more or less than competitors, and everyone can see. These changes together provide an important backdrop for why money, and early money in particular, has become an increasingly valuable metric in American politics.
Kira Sanbonmatsu
That's really helpful background. So what you're arguing is that the money race happens very early, before people are visible. But the money is very visible, and so that information is accessible. And that this is true for both men and women candidates. These signals become more important over time. And people are raising money earlier. You mentioned at the start your interest in dropout decisions. All of these things come full circle: If people don't have the right numbers early on, then they will not ever enter that primary, or we won't see them on the primary election roster.
Danielle Thomsen
Exactly. There's a winnowing of candidates at many stages in elections. There's some winnowing that keeps certain individuals out of running at all. That's a huge winnowing effect. There are other winnowing effects that happen after candidates enter but before the primary. And that's one space that I think we know less about because the data aren't as visible. And then of course we have elections that further winnow out candidates. But there's a lot of stages where money can matter in more and less visible and obvious ways. That's one of the goals of the book – to shed some new light on those ways.
Kira Sanbonmatsu
I know that the ability to raise money is also tied up with wealth and self-financing. And at CAWP we have been finding in our research that men are much more likely than women to be self-financing their congressional candidacies. We found that this cycle with our 2026 Women, Money, and Politics Watch project, and much of your work looks at the self-financing aspect. So, could you tell us a little bit about what you find about self-financing and how this is related to candidate gender and racial diversity?
Why is self-financing important and how does it affect candidate diversity?
Danielle Thomsen
I love that CAWP is looking at self-funding. I don't think we have a good handle on self-funding as much as its prevalence suggests that we should. I think the perceptions around self-funding don't fit as neatly into the more complicated empirical reality of self-funding. In large part, I think the set perception is that very rich self-funders – multi-millionaires who self-fund – lose, except for in a handful of cases. But in general, that self-funding doesn't yield electoral wins. And it is the case that fully self-funded candidates – candidates who self-fund over 90% of their early money or their pre-primary money – fare worse on average, and they don't benefit from their money in the sense of it leading to more later contributions or at helping them to win directly.
But it's also the case that a lot of candidates do self-fund. Among non-incumbent general election winners, around 40% of them self-funded at least $10,000 in their first quarterly report. It is a very widespread strategy, and yet we don't really have an understanding of what drives variation in self-funding to the degree of its prevalence.
In the paper with Savannah Plaskon, we look at early self-funding among white, Black, Latino, and Asian men and women, and we find, too, that self-funding differs dramatically by candidate race and gender. White men self-fund three times as much as Black men, Black women, and Latinas. To put numbers on this, this is about $60,000 [for white men] compared to around $15,000 for Black men, Black women, and Latinas, on average. White men self-fund significantly more than white women as well as Latino men, who each self-fund about $30,000 respectively. Asian men are also expected to self-fund about one and a half times as much as Asian women – about $50,000 versus $30,000.
And we argue that these early money disparities in both early individual contributions, as well as self-funding, they're likely to reflect broader inequalities in wealth because these funds are most likely to come from personal and professional networks as well as candidates' own pockets. So to look at this further, we use financial disclosures from the House Clerk's office that were filed by candidates – so not just winners who were elected, but candidates who both won and lost. And we show that Black and Latino candidates report far lower levels of wealth than white and Asian candidates. In particular, Black and Latino non-incumbents make up 10% of those in the top wealth quintile, but 36% of those in the bottom. White non-incumbents make up 84% of those in the top wealth quintile, but only 59% of those in the bottom.
We think these early resource disparities which matter for the trajectory of the candidates' campaigns seem to be, at least in part, associated with longstanding racial disparities in wealth. And I think that self-funding is a strategy that is so widely used that we certainly need to understand what drives or what influences variation in access to this resource – even if most candidates are using it as a supplementary strategy rather than a substitution. It is not the case that most of those who self-fund exclusively self-fund. Very few of them do. Most candidates who self-fund use it to jumpstart their campaigns and supplement this money with support from others….
Kira Sanbonmatsu
Your research sheds light on a lot of those pre-primary, behind-the-scenes dynamics of fundraising. Based on what you're finding, what advice would you give to non-incumbent women about what's needed nowadays to put together a credible congressional campaign?
What do women candidates need to know?
Danielle Thomsen
Difficult question. My thinking has evolved a bit on this. I find the money chase pretty disheartening after talking with many candidates – disheartening from a normative perspective. Candidates have to spend all this time and money, often talking to donors who live well outside their district, just to get on the map, just to be seen as viable. I was actually asked [once] on another podcast whether I'd advise my students to give money to candidates, and I said probably not because I think there's too much money in politics and much of it doesn't seem to be devoted to contacting voters or doing things that we think are normatively important activities for a campaign to do.
But candidates do operate in politics as it is currently. So I would say that if you want to maximize your impact on the choices in November, because so many of these seats are safe and the odds are good whether a Democrat or Republican will win in November, then: donate early in the race before the choices are established. Early money shapes congressional elections in many ways and helps candidates at a very critical stage in their campaigns. So while I think we need real structural change and spending limits, in particular, I would advise non-incumbent women to raise as much early money as they can. The most successful non-incumbents – these are the general election winners – they usually raise a substantial amount of money from individual and large-dollar donors at the beginning of the race. So, about half of their early money is coming from max-out donors, in particular.
Of course, fundraising is not a determinant of election outcomes. It does not buy one an office. But it does enable candidates to access important material goods like staff and advertisements and it contributes to perceptions about their viability and strength which benefits them in multiple ways across the election cycle.
Kira Sanbonmatsu
That sounds like very practical advice based on a lot of analysis and also a dose of pragmatism. So thanks for sharing that with our audience. This leads directly into another question I wanted to ask you. At CAWP we've been very interested in the donor side of the equation. Our research has been focused – not only on the situation of candidates and their fundraising – but what's happening with the gender breakdown of donors. And we find that men donors are giving more money to congressional candidates than women donors and that political giving varies by donor race and ethnicity as well. I know you're focused on the candidate side, but can your work shed any light on these donor gaps that we're seeing at CAWP?
What about gender gaps in political giving?
Danielle Thomsen
Yeah, you're right. I'm just kind of entering that area. But my work with Michele Swers looked at this question a bit from the perspective of candidate attributes. And we found that the partisan donor pools are friendlier to the emergence of liberal Democratic women than they are to Republican women. Democratic donors also exhibit what is called a gender affinity effect in which men give more to male candidates and women favor female candidates. Female Democratic donors, in particular, seem to value the election of liberal Democratic women. But Republican male and female donors do not appear to focus on candidate gender much at all, in terms of [being] more or less likely to give.
In my more recent work, I do think personal and professional networks are very likely to differ by gender. And knowing what we know about disparities in who has money, just look at the mega-donors in general elections right now; they're virtually all men. It's not surprising that race and gender shapes how candidates put together campaign war chests and the hurdles that are associated with putting together different kinds of war chests.
Kira Sanbonmatsu
Can you say a little bit more about that friends and family network?… We've come full circle about what needs to happen with those early fundraising strategies and how these structural inequalities around wealth and networks might affect those early quarters.
How does candidate gender impact early fundraising?
Danielle Thomsen
If you ask candidates who they first turn to when they launched their campaigns to ask for money, one candidate said, "You break out your Rolodex and you call everyone you know from who you went to kindergarten with to who you work with now." So this quarter is even called the "friends and family quarter” by candidates, by consultants, by people who are working on the ground in campaigns. And what they do is call anyone and everyone they know who could plausibly support their campaign. And given the nature of friendships and workplace environments, it would be unsurprising if these networks were gendered in very clear ways, with men more likely to be in networks with men, and women, more likely to have more women in their networks. Not exclusively, of course, but talking about the balance of people's networks. And we know that, from some of CAWP's excellent work and others, that men have long given larger sums of money, and so the pool of available dollars is already structured by gender. The nature of campaigns means that your acquaintances are driving much of the very beginning. So a lot of the later money, which [comes from] these mega-donors and a lot of the big money, that really is clustered in just a fraction of races. I don't think this is actually the median case where you have tens of billions of dollars in spending in a median House race. It's just not.
But who your networks are shapes how well or how easy it is for you to get off the ground in the beginning. We've been looking at large dollar donations in the first week of a campaign, and in particular how wealthy candidates have an advantage in how many large dollar contributions (these are contributions over $1,000). And one of the main findings is that wealthy candidates are getting over twice as many large dollar contributions when they enter the race as less wealthy candidates. On top of that, how many large dollar contributions they're able to attract stays higher for a longer period – their first 10 to 12 weeks in the race – [compared with] less wealthy candidates. So they're getting an easier start. And then that start – that edge or advantage – lasts longer into the first 90-day period. There are a lot of ways in which race, gender, class, and even age interact to shape who is able to run a viable campaign.
Kira Sanbonmatsu
That's really powerful evidence you have in that research. And I was really struck by the lasting effects; those initial disparities really separate candidates as you move forward. I think your book finds that experienced candidates have become more likely to have to drop out because of fundraising – that even for candidates who come into a race with experience, these fundraising discrepancies can really have an impact.
Why do experienced candidates drop out?
Danielle Thomsen
Exactly, and I think another surprising part of this is that experienced candidates who struggle to raise money are the most likely to drop out. And one reason for this is because they know how important fundraising is for their likely electoral odds. And so this metric is really being used in so many ways including changing the decision of candidates who have already thought a lot about whether it's a good idea to run in a certain year. So even candidates who have decided in a certain year – the state legislators who are really well positioned to not only run a strong campaign but to win – they decide [that] if they struggle to raise money [it] is a good indicator that they're going to [continue to] struggle and not be able to assemble the coalition that they need….
And this is newer. If you compare dropout rates in the pre-2000 period, experienced candidates who struggled to raise money were a little more likely to drop out. But today the numbers are just much, much larger. It's about 25% of experienced candidates who struggle to raise money are expected to drop out, whereas the numbers were much lower – under 10% in the 1980s and 1990s.
Kira Sanbonmatsu
And so one implication might be [that] in those early stages, if parties, gatekeepers, and the media were to take a more holistic view of candidates and become less reliant on the money signal, it sounds like that might make our primaries more competitive and make sure we get the best people. And it sounds to me, as well, that there's room for more women to get involved as donors. These disparities that you've been talking about, some of it [might] be offset by attracting new people to give early in the race…. and dovetailing with the work we've been doing at the Center, maybe there is a greater role for women to pay attention to these early dynamics of races, even before the primary.
Why does women’s political giving matter?
Danielle Thomsen
Exactly. Women are such a sizable group in the population that are underdeveloped as a source of this kind of political power. It's tricky how much we want spending to just continue to grow further, but in terms of participating in politics and having a voice in what happens in our politics and our elections, this is an area where women could engage more if asked to do so.
Kira Sanbonmatsu
Yes. And that supports a lot of what we communicate at CAWP about women donors: that, as you said, they're an underdeveloped source of participation and that they could grow in terms of their role.
Danielle Thomsen
Exactly. And I think the consequences … are really enormous in terms of not only changing the makeup of legislative institutions but changing the makeup of the ballot and the choices that people have and the messages that we hear as voters before election day. Women have long been known to have different priorities, different life experiences than men, and having more of this represented in electoral politics is an important part of democracy.
Kira Sanbonmatsu
It's a very powerful message, and of what's at stake with your findings. So thanks so much for joining us. I wanted to ask if there's anything else that you want to add that we should know about how gender connects to money and congressional elections before we wrap up.
Danielle Thomsen
One thing I would like to do is highlight CAWP's work and applaud all the work that CAWP has done for a very long time, and more recently, showcasing the variation in fundraising across both race and gender, and at multiple levels of office. As an empirical political scientist, I know that this is very hard to do. It requires a tremendous amount of resources and work, but these data are so crucial for documenting the differences in campaigns that we're talking about now. Without data discussing these differences, it is virtually impossible – at least to do so systematically. And stepping back and thinking about "the why" and some of the topics we just discussed is … we care about resources because they matter for whether candidates can tell their story to the public. And data work being done by CAWP – and really being led by CAWP – provides such a service to academics and the public to help us understand the factors that matter for candidate entry and success. So I want to thank you all for the really vital work that you do.
Kira Sanbonmatsu
Well on behalf of CAWP and our team, thank you for that recognition. It's work that we really care about and so the fact that it can reach a broad audience, including experts like yourself who have paved the way for this information in the academy [and] also out in the world, that's really wonderful to hear. Thank you for your work, which has been an inspiration to a lot of what we do at CAWP in this space, and for writing your book; and for sharing your newer work with your co-authors. We really appreciate your time. Thanks for joining us.
Danielle Thomsen
Thank you for having me. It was great to be here.